What went wrong for the left this election?

Share
What went wrong for the left this election?
The parties of left have fallen short of expectations in an election that remains too close to call.

While the election outcome remains uncertain, a National-led coalition looks increasingly likely. Jack McDonald and Justine Sachs examine why the left fell short of expectations – and what it will take to rebuild.


New Zealand's election has delivered one of the most extraordinary results in recent political history.

For the first time, Labour and National have both fallen below 30% of the party vote, while the Greens and ACT have recorded their strongest-ever results and Opportunity appears set to enter Parliament.

But while the final outcome remains uncertain, the result is already a major disappointment for the left. Despite widespread dissatisfaction with the coalition government and difficult economic conditions, Labour has failed to translate that discontent into a decisive electoral victory. With special votes still to be counted, a National-led government remains the more likely outcome.

So what went wrong?

In the latest episode of In Brief, Ollie Neas is joined by Jack MacDonald, Te Kaihautū Māori at the Public Service Association, and Justine Sachs, an Auckland-based union organiser.

The discussion examines whether Labour's cautious, small-target campaign failed to inspire voters, whether the left was outmanoeuvred on strategic voting, and the impact of declining turnout, changes to electoral rules and the influence of wealthy donors.

Watch the full conversation below and subscribe to Public Interest for more discussions making sense of politics and power in Aotearoa.

This episode was edited by Jeremy Leveridge.